French Drain vs Area Drain: Which Does Your Yard Need?
An area drain catches water sitting on top of the ground. A French drain catches water soaking in the soil. Here is how to tell which problem you have.
The short answer
If you see puddles in the same spots, start with area drains. If the ground stays soggy and spongy with no clear puddle, you need a French drain. If water runs toward the house, you may need grading first.
| French drain | Area drain | |
|---|---|---|
| Catches | Water in the soil | Water on the surface |
| What you see | Gravel line or nothing | Grates at low spots |
| Pipe | Perforated, in washed rock | Solid, from basin to outlet |
| Best for | Soggy lawns, wet slab edges | Puddles, patios, low corners |
| Typical Houston cost | $25 to $45 per foot | $1,500 to $4,500 per system |
Why Houston yards often need both
Houston clay drains slowly, so heavy rain becomes surface puddles first. Then the soil stays wet for days. Area drains move the puddles fast; the French drain dries out the soil after.
A simple test
After a heavy rain, walk the yard. Mark puddles with flags. Come back 24 hours later. Puddles still there point to area drains or grading. No puddles but squishy ground points to a French drain.
Next: French drain installation, area drains and catch basins, yard grading, or the cost guide.
Wet yard after the last storm?
Call now and talk to a local drainage pro. Free quote, no obligation.
Common questions
Which is cheaper, a French drain or an area drain?
Per job, area drains are often cheaper because they use less trench. In Houston, many yards end up needing both.
Can one system do both?
Yes. Catch basins can feed into the same outlet as a French drain, but the solid pipe from the basins should not run through the perforated pipe.
What about downspouts?
Give them their own solid pipe. Roof water can overload a French drain.